Scholarly vs. Popular Articles
Check with your instructor to determine if articles from non-scholarly publications are acceptable; oftentimes instructors restrict research to scholarly sources.
| |
Scholarly Journals |
Popular Magazines |
| |
|
Examples
|
- Sociological Review
- Economic Botany
- Journal of Asian Studies
- New England Journal of Medicine
|
- PC World
- Newsweek
- Psychology Today
- National Geographic
|
| |
|
Content and
Format
|
- Lengthy, signed articles; usually contain an abstract summarizing the main points
- Reports of original research
- In-depth analysis of topics
- Statistical information
- Substantial book reviews
- Refereed/peer reviewed to ensure quality standards of scholarship
|
- Short articles, sometimes signed
- Current events and news
- Brief, factual information
- Interviews
- Some brief book reviews
|
| |
|
Language and
Audience
|
- College-level vocabulary
- Specialized language of the discipline
- Written for other academics and experts
|
- Non-technical vocabulary
- Written for general readers
|
| |
|
Authors
|
- Researchers, academics, scholars
- Look for credentials, e.g., Ph.D. or affiliation with a university
|
|
| |
|
Sources
|
- Footnotes and bibliographies
- Extensive documentation
|
- Few footnotes
- Frequently no bibliography
|
| |
|
Publishers
|
- Professional organizations, universities, research institutes, and scholarly presses
|
- Commercial/trade publisher
|
| |
|
Graphics
|
- Graphs, charts, and tables
- Ads are very rare
|
- Many graphics and photos
- Abundant advertising; full-page color ads
|
| |
|